Police Probe Pioneering Hip Surgeon Over Bone Hoarding Claims

Police are investigating claims that a renowned surgeon may have kept thousands of bones from patients he operated on.

Derek McMinn, referred to on his website as the ‘father of modern hip resurfacing’, was responsible for a type of surgery that helped former world number one tennis player Sir Andy Murray return to topflight competition.

Mr McMinn has since been suspended from Edgbaston Hospital in Birmingham.

The Independent reported that he allegedly kept the bones of at least 5224 of his patients over a quarter of a century.

Hospital owner, Circle Health Group, said it took the matter “incredibly seriously”.

Investigation Under Human Tissue Law

It is understood that West Mercia Police are investigating an allegation of Breach of Statutory Licensing requirements under the Human Tissue Act 2004. Under the law, it may be an offence to store human tissue for certain purposes without a licence.

The inquiry was launched after referral by the Human Tissue Authority (HTA).

An HTA spokesperson confirmed that it carried out an investigation after concerns were raised by previous hospital owners BMI Healthcare in August 2019, and by the Care Quality Commission following an inspection.

The HTA said its own investigation involved BMI Healthcare staff, as well as Mr McMinn.

The Authority said it was unable to comment further as the matter was now the subject of a police investigation.

The General Medical Council (GMC) said it was “aware of concerns” and had asked BMI Healthcare to send investigation reports and other relevant evidence.

A GMC spokesperson said: “We can and will take action where there is evidence that a doctor poses a risk to patients or public confidence in the profession.”

The GMC confirmed that Mr McMinn was currently registered with a licence to practise.

‘No Stone Unturned’

A spokesperson for Circle Health Group said: “We only acquired the hospital in June and we will leave no stone unturned in investigating these historic issues: they have all been reported to the appropriate authorities and we will co-operate closely with regulators to resolve them.”

The spokesperson confirmed that Mr McMinn’s contract with the Edgbaston hospital had been terminated.

According to Mr McMinn’s website, he graduated from St Thomas’ Hospital in London, and is one of the globe’s leading hip and knee experts, and the inventor of the Birmingham Hip Resurfacing technique.

He has performed more than 3500 hip resurfacings and over 6000 total hip replacements.

He is said to have developed an alternative treatment to hip replacement after seeing poor results in young people.

Source Article

Swedes indict surgeon for stem-cell windpipe transplants


STOCKHOLM (AP) — A Swedish prosecutor on Tuesday indicted on charges of aggravated assault a surgeon believed to have made headlines in 2011 for carrying out the world’s the first stem-cell windpipe transplants, saying three people had laboratory-made tracheas implanted at Sweden’s leading hospital.

Although Mikael Bjork, director of Public Prosecution, didn’t name him, Swedish news agency TT said the surgeon was Dr. Paolo Macchiarini, who was once considered a pioneer in regenerative medicine, credited with creating the world’s first windpipe partially made from a patient’s own stem cells.

In December 2018, Bjork decided to reopen a previously discontinued investigation into three cases. Additional written evidence was obtained and more interviews were held with individuals in Sweden, Belgium, Britain, the United States and Spain, Bjork said in a statement.

“It has become clear to me that the operations were carried out in conflict with science and proven experience,” he added.

Macchiarini was fired from Sweden’s prestigious Karolinska Institute in March 2016 for breaching medical ethics after being accused of falsifying his resume and misrepresenting his work.

When Macchiarini’s first windpipe transplant was reported in the medical journal Lancet in 2008, it was hailed as a breakthrough in regenerative medicine. Macchiarini’s new airway — partly made using stem cells from the patient — was thought to herald a new era where new organs could be made in the laboratory.

Despite an independent commission in Sweden that found numerous problems in Macchiarini’s work, the Lancet has so far declined to retract the study.

Bjork said the operation had caused the victims “serious physical injuries and great suffering,” and “have been carried out with absolutely no legal basis.”

“I have made the assessment that the three operations are therefore to be considered as aggravated assault,” Bjork said. “It is the former surgeon at Karolinska University Hospital who alone should bear the criminal responsibility.”

Macchiarini earlier had disputed the accusations, saying they were false.

Of the 20 patients Macchiarini operated on to provide them with an artificial windpipe — from countries including Spain, Russian, Iceland, Britain and the U.S. — only three are still alive. Critics say Macchiarini skirted medical ethics to carry out dangerous procedures with no proven benefit and that he fabricated descriptions of this patients’ conditions.

Bjork declined to explain why he believes the operations were carried out with no legal basis. These details and explanations will first be made at the main hearing, he said, adding no date for that was set yet at the District Court in Solna, in northern Stockholm.

Last year, an Italian court sentenced Macchiarini to 16 months in prison for forging documents and abuse of office.


Olsen reported from Copenhagen, Denmark. Maria Cheng in London contributed to this report.

Source Article

Difference Between A Periodontist And Oral Surgeon

When you’re on the lookout for a dentist in Derby, you are truly spoiled for selection (in contrast to some parts of the UK the place patients are compelled to attend lengthy intervals for dental appointments). Proper rear place :- The operator is behind and slightly to the fitting of the left arm is positioned around the patient’ is the position of choice for most lingual and incisal(occlusal)surfaces of the maxillary enamel are considered in the mouth mirror.Mandibular tooth can be seen in direct imaginative and prescient.

Your dentist makes positive that your tooth remain in ok situation that you just’re by no means in any serious danger of main tooth issues. Dentists are professionals who practice dentistry. Many offices provide in-home remedies that leave your tooth whiter in just one visit or take house trays that you just apply your self over two weeks.

There are some folks that select to eat solely delicate meals as an alternative of harder meals to keep away from chipping a tooth and should go to the dentist. At all times brush your teeth and different mouth parts gently and without utilizing a lot stress.Extreme force can harm the gums and nonetheless can contribute to the erosion of enamel.

Left untreated, periodontal might cause vital bone loss, delicate tissue loss alongside the enamel roots and the gums to recede usually inflicting tooth to loosen, making tooth extraction the only possibility to revive oral well being and stop neighboring tooth from additionally being affected.

So as to make sure you make a sound choice and discover the very best dentist in Derby, it’s essential to do three issues: 1. work out what you’re searching for, 2. develop a list of prospective dentists in Derby, and 3. slender down your list to only one or two dentists that you’ll truly ebook appointments with.…